10 Common Shopify Subscription Mistakes That Hurt Growth — And How to Fix Them
- Updated: April 11, 2025
Table of Contents
eCommerce subscriptions can supercharge your eCommerce growth, but only if you avoid the typical mistakes that hold brands back.
Understanding and fixing Shopify subscription mistakes is crucial because even small missteps can lead to high churn, poor customer retention, and missed revenue opportunities, especially in the competitive eCommerce subscription space.
This blog uncovers the 10 common subscription pitfalls Shopify merchants face and offers practical fixes to optimize performance, boost LTV, and ensure steady growth.
Mistake #1: Choosing the Wrong Shopify Subscription App
Many merchants jump into the subscription model using a generic or poorly supported Shopify subscription app, only to realize later that it lacks the features needed to retain customers and scale effectively. Whether it’s limited billing flexibility, poor customer support, or weak integration with checkout and fulfillment tools, choosing the wrong app can stall growth early on.
How to fix:
Your choice of subscription management app sets the foundation for your recurring revenue model. Look for a solution that offers:
- Flexible billing intervals and product bundling
- Seamless integration with Shopify Checkout
- Automated failed payment recovery
- Subscription pause, swap, or cancellation options
- Customer self-management features
- Strong support and scalability
Driftcharge is built specifically for Shopify and offers robust capabilities for managing and growing your eCommerce subscriptions.
Mistake #2: Complex or Confusing Subscription Options
A confusing or rigid subscription plan can discourage customers from signing up or cause high churn rates. If customers don’t see clear value Offering too many subscription plans or presenting them with unclear language often leads to friction during the buying process. When shoppers face a cluttered or confusing selection, they are more likely to abandon the page altogether. Complexity kills conversions, especially in the eCommerce subscription space, where speed and clarity matter.
How to fix:
When choices are simple and benefits are clear, customers are more likely to subscribe with confidence.
- Simplify your subscription offerings.
- Limit the number of plan choices and highlight the key benefits of each clearly
- Use straightforward language, clean layouts, and visual cues like badges or icons to guide the customer’s decision.
- Focus on value, convenience, and flexibility.
Mistake #3: Ignoring Subscription Cart Abandonment
One of the most overlooked Shopify subscription mistakes is relying on generic cart recovery flows that aren’t optimized for subscription-based products. A standard abandoned cart email might work for one-time purchases, but subscription customers need a different kind of nudge, especially when trust and commitment are involved.
How to fix:
To solve this, build a more tailored and timely cart recovery strategy. Here’s how:
- Segment subscribers from one-time shoppers in your marketing automation tool.
- Trigger a personalized SMS or email within 1 hour of abandonment.
- Make the offer time-limited to create urgency.
- Use apps like Klaviyo, Postscript, or your subscription platform’s built-in tools to automate the message.
Mistake #4: No Trial, Discount, or Intro Offer
One of the most common Shopify subscription mistakes is expecting customers to commit without offering a reason to try the product first. Without a clear incentive, like a trial, a discount, or an intro offer, many potential subscribers drop off before completing their first purchase. It’s a missed opportunity to build trust and boost conversion rates.
How to fix:
To solve this, build a more tailored and timely cart recovery strategy. Here’s how:
- Free Trials : Let customers experience your product without risk. Even a 7-day trial or sample can significantly increase conversions.
- First-Month Discounts: Offer a reduced price for the first subscription cycle (e.g., Get your first month for just $5 ).
- Subscribe & Save Offers: Highlight how customers can save 10–20% by subscribing instead of making one-time purchases.
- Bundle Incentives: Combine popular products into discounted subscription bundles to add more perceived value.
Mistake #5: Not Segmenting Subscribers
A common yet costly Shopify subscription mistake is treating all subscribers the same, whether they’ve just signed up or have been loyal for a year. Sending identical emails to a new 1-month customer and a long-term 12-month subscriber creates a disconnect. This lack of personalization not only feels impersonal but can also lead to churn and engagement drop-off.
How to fix:
To avoid these subscription issues, you need to segment your subscriber base based on loyalty, lifecycle stage, and behavior. Here’s how to fix this subscription problem:
- Tag subscribers by tenure: Use your best subscription app to tag users (e.g., 1-month, 3-month, 6-month+).
- Personalize communication: Tailor your messages—like “As a 6-month VIP, here’s an exclusive reward…” or “Thanks for joining—here’s how to get the most from your first month.”
- Reward loyalty: Long-term subscribers should receive special offers, early access to new products, or extra loyalty points.
- Lifecycle automation: Use tools like Klaviyo or your subscription app’s CRM to create automated flows based on subscription age or frequency.
Mistake #6: Ignoring Failed Payment Recovery
One of the most overlooked subscription problems in the eCommerce subscription model is failed payment recovery. When a customer’s card is declined during renewal, many stores simply let the subscription lapse, resulting in lost revenue and customer churn. Without a proper recovery system, you’re leaving money on the table every month.
How to fix:
To protect your recurring revenue, choose a Subscription Management App that offers built-in dunning management, the process of recovering failed payments through automated reminders and retries. Here’s what to do:
- Enable auto-retry for failed transactions: Most advanced apps allow multiple retry attempts before canceling the subscription.
- Send friendly reminders: Notify customers via email or SMS about the failed payment and prompt them to update billing info.
- Use dunning tools: Choose platforms like Driftcharge that offer automated workflows to recover lost payments.
- Track recovery rates: Monitor failed vs. recovered payments to optimize your recovery strategy over time.
Mistake #7: Not Optimizing the Subscriber Experience
One of the biggest subscription problems merchants overlook is the subscriber’s experience after checkout. If customers can’t easily manage their subscription, like updating payment details, skipping deliveries, or changing products, they are more likely to cancel out of frustration. No login access or a clunky interface creates unnecessary friction.
How to fix it:
Improving post-purchase experience is essential to reduce churn and increase long-term retention. Here’s how to fix this with the right tools:
- Use a powerful Subscription Management App: The best subscription app allows customers to access their own dashboard to manage, pause, skip, or cancel their subscriptions easily.
- Enable self-service: Let users handle routine changes without needing to contact support.
- Customize the dashboard UI: Make it mobile-friendly, branded, and easy to navigate.
- Proactive notifications: Use SMS or email to alert subscribers before renewals, upcoming shipments, or changes in pricing.
Mistake #8: Lack of Retention or Win-Back Strategies
Many merchants focus heavily on acquiring new subscribers but neglect what happens after the sale. Without a solid retention plan, you risk losing subscribers due to inactivity, frustration, or boredom, leading to high churn and lower customer lifetime value. This is a common subscription problem that silently eats into growth.
How to fix it:
To maintain momentum and build long-term loyalty, your subscription management app should support retention workflows.
- Win-back emails: Set up automated emails for customers who canceled or became inactive. Offer incentives to rejoin—like an exclusive discount or bonus product.
- Loyalty & rewards programs: Encourage subscribers to stick around longer by rewarding them for milestones (e.g., 3-month subscriber = free gift).
- Surprise perks: Delight your long-term subscribers with unexpected bonuses like product upgrades or early access to new items.
- Track engagement signals: Use your subscription app to monitor engagement and proactively reach out to customers showing signs of churn.
Mistake #9: Not Tracking the Right Metrics
Many merchants rely solely on total subscribers as a success metric, overlooking deeper insights that actually impact growth.
Here’s what goes wrong:
- Not monitoring Monthly Recurring Revenue (MRR)
- Ignoring churn rate (lost subscribers over time)
- No visibility into Customer Lifetime Value (LTV)
- Missing cohort behavior (how different signup groups perform)
How to fix this:
To make smarter decisions, combine Google Analytics with your Shopify subscription app’s dashboard to:
- Track cohort retention over time
- Monitor churn and failed payments
- Measure LTV and average subscription length
- Identify drop-off points and optimize accordingly
Mistake #10: Poor Post-Purchase Experience
One of the most common yet overlooked Shopify subscription mistakes is neglecting what happens after a customer subscribes. Weak onboarding, no confirmation email, and lack of follow-up can make customers feel unsure or forgotten, leading to early cancellations and lower satisfaction.
How to fix it:
A strong post-purchase experience builds trust, reinforces value, and reduces churn. Here’s how to get it right:
- Automate welcome emails: Send a branded, helpful welcome message immediately after signup.
- Deliver instant value: Include tips, guides, or exclusive content related to their subscription product. Make them feel like they made the right choice.
- Provide easy support access: Ensure customers know where and how to get help. Include FAQs, support links, and contact info in all onboarding emails.
- Follow up regularly: Check in with customers after their first delivery and ask for feedback or offer support.
To Wrap Up
Ignoring these Shopify subscription mistakes isn’t just about fixing what’s broken. It’s about unlocking consistent, scalable growth for your eCommerce brand.
From choosing the right subscription management app to optimizing retention and post-purchase experience, each small improvement contributes to a more reliable subscription model.
If you are serious about growing your recurring revenue, now’s the time to audit your current subscription setup.
Tools like Driftcharge Subscription Management App can make this process easier, offering flexible billing options, automated workflows, powerful retention tools, and seamless Shopify integration.
Driftcharge is launching soon. Be among the first to experience it. Join the Waitlist Now, and get early access.
Ganesh Pawar
Join the waitlist now
Limited early access. Early joiners receive additional discounts on premium features.
Discover how
